Old Fashioned Southern Coconut Pie (Vintage Recipe) - Restless Chipotle (2024)

This unique dessert is perfect for the coconut lovers in the family. It's similar to a chess pie or a pecan pie.

🗝️ Key takeaways

• This is a coconut lover's dream. It tastes similar to and has the texture of, pecan pie but with coconut!
• Southern coconut pie is great all year long! It works as well at Thanksgiving as it does at Easter.
• (techniques they'll learn or some other informative fact from the post)

From potlucks to cookouts and especially the holiday dessert table, Southern coconut pie is versatile and delicious all year-'round.

This particular recipe is quite vintage and has lasted the test of time because each bite's like a little bit of heaven in your mouth.

For best results, serve with a huge dollop of homemade whipped cream!

🧾 Ingredients

📖Variations

I love how the simple ingredients shine through in this baked coconut pie, you really don't need to add much to it. However, here are a few possible variations:

• Use your favorite unbaked pie crust. I think this dessert recipe tastes best with homemade pie crust, but it's so good you can get away with using a frozen pie crust, too.
• I use a 10-inch pie crust and pie dish, but you could use a 9-inch pie plate, as long as it's a deep dish.
• Instead of vanilla extract, use an equal amount of vanilla bean paste.
• You can add some chopped pecans to the coconut mix if you'd like to create a unique hybrid pie. The two flavors go together like shrimp and grits!
• Some people like to add a teaspoon or so of lemon juice to the pie filling. You can't really taste the juice, but rumor has it that the acidity helps balance out the sweetness and make an even fluffier pie.
• Serve with whipped cream, Cool Whip, or a scoop of vanilla ice cream!

🔪 Instructions

This is an overview of the ingredients. You'll find the full measurements and instructions in the green recipe card (printable) at the bottom of the page.

1. Whisk the eggs together.
2. Add the sugar, corn syrup, cooled butter, vanilla, and salt. Whisk until smooth. It *may* look a little curdled like in the images above. That's ok.
3. Stir in the coconut
4. Pour the coconut pie filling into the unbaked pie shell and bake as directed in the recipe card below.

🥫 Storage

This delicious pie can be made in advance and stored for up to three days in the refrigerator.

Just be sure to cover the room-temperature pie (or leftovers) with some plastic wrap before hiding it in the way back of the fridge so no one else can find it—our little secret!

I don't recommend freezing this pie.

Be sure to cool it all the way. Like my pecan pie it's best if it's refrigerated overnight, but the quality really takes a nose-dive if you try to freeze and thaw it.

Trust me on this one.

💭 Things to know

Expert Tip: Cool your Southern coconut pie for at least two hours before cutting it. However, for the absolute prettiest, award-winning slices, I'd recommend overnight refrigeration before serving the pie. This is typically the rule of thumb with most of everyone's favorite pie recipes. Patience is key!

• You can buy flaked, sweetened coconut in many popular grocery stores. It's moist and sweet, which is perfect. Don't use just plain coconut flakes, or your pie will lack flavor.
• Lay a sheet of aluminum foil loosely over the top of the pie about halfway through baking, or whenever you notice the crust starting to turn golden brown. Remove it during the last few minutes of baking if your pie hasn't toasted as much as you'd like.
• The pie is finished baking when it's set, but still a little wobbly in the center. If you're unsure, pop an instant-read thermometer in and look for 185 degrees F.

👩‍🍳 FAQs

• Moist, gooey, and full of holiday flavor, this Pecan Pie recipe includes a special tip to achieve a perfect bake—never over or under, again!
• Looking for something no bake? Try this two layer peanut butter pie!
• Southern Coconut Cake has three dreamy layers of fluffy coconut cake, zingy raspberry jam, and deliciously sweet white chocolate frosting!
• Tropical coconut filling, cloud-like mounds of whipped cream, and a crunchy praline filling—this Coconut Praline Pie satisfies every craving!

📞 The last word

I've heard this called French coconut pie. I have no idea, y'all. It's just delicious.

Make no mistake - once you've served this to family and friends you'll be making it a lot! It's the best coconut pie I've ever had, hands down.

Next time try this old fashioned lemon meringue pie.

If you click on the number of servings in the recipe card you can adjust the measurements up or down for the exact number of servings you need. Don't forget that you can click on "add to collection" to save it to your own, private recipe box!

If you love this recipe please give it 5 stars!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

📖 Recipe

First published - November 7, 2016. -- Last Updated -August 14, 2023 for editorial improvements.

What’s new? Check out myRestless Chipotle & Co. Store on Amazon where you'll find all kinds of nostalgic goodness!Thanks so much for being a part of Restless Chipotle!

More Homemade Southern Pie Recipes